The first-Valerio Melandri Italian blog on fundraising

Better to be cynical, that moralists ...!

Data: December 22, 2009

Receive from a former student of the master:

Dear Melandri, I was shocked to say the least from the ruling issued by a Justice of the Forum, which states that a donation of EUR 700,000-avowedly from attivita'illecite and criminals - should be accepted. The case was between the treasurer and the president of a small non-profit Italian:-it-in my opinion rightly refused to hand accettarla.Il Judge considered the prevailing "the interest of protected persons from non-profit organization" We know what you would keep in she thinks. Best Regards

ara Leda
I'd say they basically agree with the judge ... and then the land confiscated from the Mafia, used by social cooperatives in the south? Are donations to the coop social values ​​clearly from illegal activities.
I did not understand, (from recording video) but the story seems to me that the question was a rejection of pure or "moralism."
But as the great Dostoyevsky said "better to be cynical moralist." A moralist is never a step more 'and does not change anything in his life, a cynical, if sometimes sad, at least new steps and new ventures.
Discuss rules of fundraising today, in view of a session at the Festival of Fundraising, Ethics and Practice of the fundraiser. There is an Italian consulting company (Avanzi. Viageo), directed by the indefatigable David Del Maso, who has developed a system to accept donations of ethical evaluation. The first time applicable to the nonprofit world to settle such cases. At the Festival we will talk.
See you soon!
The day 06/dic/09, at 17:42, Leda remains wrote:
Dear Editor,
I was shocked to say the least from the ruling issued by a Justice of the Forum, which
states that a donation of EUR 700,000 from activity-avowedly '
illegal and criminal - should be accepted.
The case was between the treasurer and the president of a small Italian non-profit organization:
I think-it-rightly refused to accept it.
The Judge however held mainly "the interest of protected persons from non-profit organization"
We would keep her to know what you think.
Best Regards
It is detrimental
************************************************** ***************************
PS Can 'find the video with the title "Generous Donation" in the site forum
or by clicking on 20.11.09
Take a look at the video at:
http://www.video.mediaset.it/mplayer.html?sito=forum&data=2009/11/20&id=1364&from=email

I'd say they basically agree with the judge ... ... (and then the land confiscated from the Mafia, used by social cooperatives in the south? Are donations to the coop social values ​​clearly from illegal activities). I did not understand, (from recording video) but the story seems to me that the issue was a refusal by mere "moralism." But, as Dostoyevsky said, "better to be cynical moralist." And I agree! A moralist is never a step more 'and does not change anything in his life, a cynical, if sometimes sadly and "cynical", at least new steps and dare new attempts. Discuss ethical fundraising today, in view of a session at the Festival Fundraisin g of Ethics and Practice of fundraising. There is an Italian consulting company ( Avanzi. Viageo ), directed by the indefatigable David Del Maso, who has developed a system to accept donations of ethical evaluation. The first time applicable to the nonprofit world, to resolve such cases'. I spoke today with Letizia Rossi (Major Donors of Médecins Sans Frontières), in which I proposed to offer a session with Del Maso, on this. At the Festival we will talk!

See you soon!

PS And anyway, "better to be cynical moralists who" makes up the other, recognition of equal thickness, but most home: "the rules used to regulate who can not do" ... .. How much trouble, even in education for children would be solved if you apply this simple and basic "rule" .... The rule that only adjust what is not is self .... But when one leaves free to regulate, regulate almost everything they know and therefore ... the rules would be avoided. ... and then no one respects that impose more rules ... that no one respects .... That's it! My ideal world is not without rules, but the self .. that's why it is equally important to the school and the police .... You can 'find the video with the title "Generous Donation" in the site or forums on 20.11.09 clicking directly. Take a look at the video at: http://www.video.mediaset.it/mplayer.html?sito=forum&data=2009/11/20&id=1364&from=email

2 comments to post.

  1. Raffaele Picilli on December 24, 2009 wrote:

    I would say that it is better to be neither cynical nor moralists.
    Compared to the post and the story told, I believe that accepting funds is not a question of cynicism, opportunism, or morality, I think it's simply a matter of conscience. I would not accept anything, for example, funds from family or Mafia or Camorra smell from corporations or ordinary supporters who have no idea of ​​what compliance with the laws of civil society and humanity. I know, mine is a speech that will surely make you stand up little and smiling a few. I have no crystal ball to know the illegal activities of donors, but if I have the impression or the certainty that these are real, then I prefer to avoid "gifts" which I find indigestible.
    The discourse of property confiscated from the mafia is different because the owner is dishonest by the State was deprived of an asset purchased with money from illegal activities and therefore, the seizure is part of the sentence. The assignment of property confiscated from the mafia or Camorra is the recapture of the territory, is a victory of a "donor" who has just had, with nothing left. A donor who'd want to donate something.
    Merry Christmas to all!

  2. Quistelli francesco on December 28, 2009 wrote:

    Hello Valerio,
    The topic is especially close to my heart. As a component of the money fundraising and sustainability of a social cause, I believe that the pragmatic and realistic approach would be most appropriate, do not know whether or not to call it cynical, but the old "non-pecuniary olet" may be a good summary (and I know that the moralists are shaking their heads ...). The main interest is always the weakest, that to me is realism.
    In this post I had launched a provocation, a real climax (and only as such should be read!) http://quistelliblog.wordpress.com/2008/11/18/ma-tu-i-soldi-li-prendi-da- all / and here are some ideas See you soon!

Leave a comment.

You can use these XHTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <blockquote cite=""> <b> <cite> <code> <of datetime = ""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Search

  • Master in Fundraising

    Master in Fundraising

  • Translator

    Italiano flagInglese flagFrancese flagTedesco flagPortoghese flagSpagnolo flag                                    
  • What is the fund raising

  • Recent Comments

  • Categories

  • I am part of

  • Archives


  • 2004-2009 Valerio Melandri
    site made ​​with WordPress
    Theme Simplicity made ​​by David Falanga and edited by Victor Manduchi